Logo Platform
logo amplifiers simplified

Disband button on fleet panel will move all ships to hangar instead

Reply
Copied to clipboard!
7 years ago
Nov 20, 2017, 12:31:00 AM
  • Summary / Title: Disband button on fleet panel will move all ships to hangar instead 
  • Description: on the fleet panel, the "Disband" button will actually move all ships in the fleet to the hangar of the current system, instead of actually disbanding. The tooltip of the "Disband" button actually describes moving the ships to the hangar. 
  • Reproduce: Have a fleet in a owned system. Tested with United Empire on tutorial and normal campaign.
  • Reproducibility: 5/5
  • Expected Behavior: Either this button should serve for disband or moving to hangar. In either case, there should be another button somewhere for the other action. In other words, there should be a button for "Disband" and a button for "Move to hangar".
  • Version: latest as of 20/11/2017
  • Notes
  • Attachments:
0Send private message
7 years ago
Nov 20, 2017, 12:40:46 PM

I think this is actually intended functionality, and is just a little unclear with the wording. 


As far as I can tell, the "Disband" button isn't disbanding the ships, but rather disbanding the fleet - that's why it's in the center box (fleet management) as opposed to the right one (ship management). I agree though, the word choice could lead to confusion.


There is a button for what you're looking for, the "Sell" button all the way to the right. I believe it is only available in your own systems though.

0Send private message
7 years ago
Nov 20, 2017, 4:18:05 PM

Well, actually I believe that the button name "disband" does not match its functionality. Disband, conceptually, should completely eliminate the unit/fleet. That is the expected behaviour for that action in typicall strategy/4x games. On the other hand, there is clearly the need to move a unit/fleet to the hangar of a system so that action also needs to be on the interface. 


Additionally, the sell button should also exist on its own because it's behaviour is different than disband. Selling will move the item to the marketplace, I believe, with a dust profit for the player. The player might not want to put that unit in the marketplace because other players might then buy it, possibly getting units with capabilities that weren't accessible to them originally. So the player might want to disband, sell or move to hangar. All 3 distinct actions make sense to me.

0Send private message
7 years ago
Nov 21, 2017, 12:44:28 AM
iPedros wrote:

Well, actually I believe that the button name "disband" does not match its functionality. Disband, conceptually, should completely eliminate the unit/fleet. That is the expected behaviour for that action in typicall strategy/4x games. On the other hand, there is clearly the need to move a unit/fleet to the hangar of a system so that action also needs to be on the interface. 


Additionally, the sell button should also exist on its own because it's behaviour is different than disband. Selling will move the item to the marketplace, I believe, with a dust profit for the player. The player might not want to put that unit in the marketplace because other players might then buy it, possibly getting units with capabilities that weren't accessible to them originally. So the player might want to disband, sell or move to hangar. All 3 distinct actions make sense to me.


As fas as I am aware, selling doesn't actually put them to the marketplace but simply destroys the ships and gives you dust in return. As far as I'm concerned, that serves the functionality of both actually disbanding ships as well as selling them to the marketplace (same result on my end, I lose the ships and I get money).


However, I agree with you that the use of Disband is unclear. I would argue that you are in fact disbanding, but you are disbanding the fleet, not the ships - that is why it is located where it is (as opposed to the sell button). But yes, the use of the word disband is confusing and should be either clarified or replaced with a different term ("Disband Fleet", "Move to Hanger," or even a tooltip that clarifies would all solve the issue).

TL;DR It makes sense why they used the term, but I agree it should be renamed or clarified.


Updated 7 years ago.
0Send private message
0Send private message
7 years ago
Nov 21, 2017, 7:14:08 PM

dis·band

disˈband/

verb

verb: disband; 3rd person present: disbands; past tense: disbanded; past participle: disbanded; gerund or present participle: disbanding

  1. (of an organized group) break up or cause to break up and stop functioning.

    synonyms:break up, disperse, demobilize, dissolve, scatter, separate, go separate ways, part company "the unit was scheduled to disband"
    antonyms:assemble


0Send private message
7 years ago
Nov 22, 2017, 4:09:44 PM

Hello again :)


Using your example I can say the Fleet has been broken up, dispersed, demobilized (...) and the Ships were stored in the Hangar.

I'll pass your suggestion on to the writers though.


Cheers,

0Send private message
?

Click here to login

Reply
Comment

Characters : 0
No results
0Send private message