Logo Platform
logo amplifiers simplified

Chain Gang Clarity

System ManagementPopulationGUI

Reply
7 years ago
May 4, 2017, 12:43:00 AM

Hello all,


As a mainly Craver player, I've been making a lot of use out of the Chain Gang Program "improvement" to control who's population is growing within my star systems. It's very important for a Craver empire to use Chain Gang, but it's also at times frustrating and/or awkward to use because it is not very clear about how it is going to affect the system it is being used in. I'd like to suggest some improvements to make Chain Gang a little more intuitive to the player herein.


Current State

In the current game (0.3.7), Chain Gang works like this: 

  1. You select Chain Gang Program from the build queue to convert a unit of population (or 300 Food) into 300 Manpower.
  2. Chain Gang "selects" the unit of population for conversion by checking whichever pop type is currently growing in the system.
  3. Chain Gang deducts 300 Food from the system its "built" in, (usually) resulting in the loss of 1 unit of that pop type the following turn.


The Problem(s)

The main problems with the current way Chain Gang works are as follows:

  1. If you're using Chain Gang Program for the first time, you'll have no idea which unit of population is going to get used for the manpower conversion. The tooltip is of no help to you because it only tells you that it is going to take 1 Pop and turn it into 300 Manpower. It's only after you pass a turn and lose a unit of population that you'll start to clue into how Chain Gang is selecting pops for conversion.
  2. Once your system hits the maximum number of pops it can hold, you'll no longer know which unit of pop Chain Gang is going to "eat" because you can't see which unit of pop is growing anymore. This makes queuing up Chain Gang somewhat less desirable in a maxed-out system, as you have no idea which pop type you're going to lose.
  3. If you're looking to cut the population of a certain type consecutively with Chain Gang, you're gunna have a hard time. This is because the game cycles through which pop types will be growing in your systems (eg. Cravers and Haroshem on your system, 1st pop unit is Craver, 2nd is Haroshem, 3rd Craver, and so forth, generally speaking). Because Chain Gang makes its selection depending on system growth, you'd have to wait for every other unit of pop in order to "eat" the right pop. It only gets worse as you add more pop types to the system.
  4. If you have more than 300 food production on your system, it becomes impossible to cull any unit of population on the system, effectively divorcing Chain Gang from its main effect (at least, in my opinion) -- Population control.


Suggested Changes

Problems 1 to 3 could be solved fairly simply in the following, I think: If there was a selection box of some sort (perhaps something like the mock-up I've done below) with the icon of the pop type beside the turn counter when putting Chain Gang Program into the build queue, the player would know which unit of pop is going to be consumed by it. In addition, the selection box could be clicked to select which unit of pop you want Chain Gang to consume via a wheel graphic (or something else easy to decipher -- I did what I could with Paint ) displaying all the pop types you have in the system.



Problem 4 is more of a mechanical one, but it's nonetheless fairly simple to solve (in theory) -- when Chain Gang completes, it subtracts 1 unit of the selected population from the system for the Manpower conversion, rather than consuming 300 Food from the growth of the system. This would separate Chain Gang from Food and allow it to continue to be useful for population control for the entirety of the game.



Updated 5 days ago.
0Send private message

Out of Vision

The OUT OF VISION status is given by the dev team to ideas that are not compatible with their vision of the game or technically not feasible.

The-Cat-o-Nine-Tales

DEV The-Cat-o-Nine-Tales

status updated 5 years ago

Selecting the population which would be removed is out of vision for what Chain Gang Program is (a quick manpower boost), though we admit the feedback could be clearer.

Comments

Reply
Copied to clipboard!
7 years ago
May 6, 2017, 11:01:02 PM

Sounds solid. I'll give it an upvote. 


This is something that bugs me. Amplitude amkes some "Abillitys" to unclear. Would be nice if we could choose the Population everytime we use Chain Gang. Or something else that uses the Pops.


Also what's your steam name? I would like to play with you sometimes.

0Send private message
0Send private message
7 years ago
May 8, 2017, 8:09:44 AM

You first three points was asked many times. Good suggestion for GUI in this way.

About point 4 never looked at this, but well spotted and good proposal.

My +1.

0Send private message
7 years ago
May 8, 2017, 9:44:45 PM

Thank you for this, I was running into the exact same problem the other day. The right pop was never getting deleted.

Upvoted

0Send private message
7 years ago
May 15, 2017, 2:32:04 PM

I've not used Chain Gang yet, personally, but Considering what was explained, I agree with this completely.  +1

0Send private message
7 years ago
May 17, 2017, 7:18:53 AM

I'd like to be able to queue multiple chain gangs, which should make it still work on high food systems.

0Send private message

Nice to have

The NICE TO HAVE status is given by the dev team to ideas they would like to have in the game.

Dagart

DEV Dagart

status updated 7 years ago

we should at least know what population will be chainganged
0Send private message
7 years ago
Jun 30, 2017, 3:09:55 PM

How about adding a drop box where a chosen population can be placed (similar to space transport of population).

0Send private message
7 years ago
Jul 5, 2017, 7:03:17 AM

This would be extremely usefull for pop control. Also, i've never thought about point 4, but it surely looks like a bug to me. Chain gang has been designed as a way to boost manpower for the tax of costing one population (like military service, you lose civilians/workers/taxpayers but gain soldier). If you produce more than 300 food in one system you efectively turn food into soldiers, which is silly.

0Send private message
7 years ago
Jan 19, 2018, 4:42:39 AM

Selectable conscription this looks like an idea I had.

0Send private message
0Send private message

Out of Vision

The OUT OF VISION status is given by the dev team to ideas that are not compatible with their vision of the game or technically not feasible.

The-Cat-o-Nine-Tales

DEV The-Cat-o-Nine-Tales

status updated 5 years ago

Selecting the population which would be removed is out of vision for what Chain Gang Program is (a quick manpower boost), though we admit the feedback could be clearer.

0Send private message
?

Click here to login

Reply
Comment