Hi,
After reading this thread from @Strife, I'm start thinking that the growth rate of trade companies needs to be tweaked. If you look at his numbers, the income from trade can be obscene in mid-game, making your economy and your game only a matter of I'll buy everything I need and don't care anymore.
It also can eliminate any worries and gameplay interest in getting the luxuries you need to lvl up your systems (his getting 999 of each every turn).
Actually I liked the idea on GDD about trade, and how it is implemented, but I think this exponential growth may be pernicious for an interesting gamplay in mid or late game, as you'll always be getting far more dust and luxuries than you need.
What I actually think is that underlying numbers should be tweaked to create a logarithmic instead of an exponential growht (no changes in the system, or at least in what players are seeing in GUI).
Why I suggest logarithmic and not another model, because:
- You'll get quicker growth when unlocking these techs and building your first trade companies, thus:
- Making them more rewarding (or at least the immediate impression)
- Giving you a thrust in your dust and luxuries when you need it more.
- You'll get an slower growth in late game, thus:
- Depending in your empire size you'll have headaches due to your dust income, and some interest in getting luxuries from diplo/market/invading.
- Mitigates the mid/late game snowballing in your economy, that in most 4X make this part of game boring.
As everything, and to be fair, I see two drawbacks (may be there are more, so you can put your comments):
- This mid/late game snowballing may be limitaed by dust inflation planned for update 2, making no need to change actual numbers. May be even you'll need it if you want to be competitive (we'll see soon). But I think this shouldn't be the case, as if this is like this it will end up with very high incomes and prices, making this only inflated numbers without any real meaning, and can even be punishing for trade-adverse players or factions.
- It may be punishing on higher difficulties. Still not sure about that. If you read thi linked post @SirBagel reached it on hard, and @Strife didn't mentioned which difficulty was using.
Have in mind that I think this drawbacks are only appliable to dust, as IMO avoiding the 999 luxuries per turn should be avoided even if the dust growth is managed in another way.
As final note, I undesrstand almost everyone here knows differences between exponential and logarithmic growth, but (not wanting to insult) if someone has doubts, this graph is explanatory of what I'm telling:
Just to clarify again: don't expect changes in system itself, as I think Amplitude did a good job and had very good ideas on it, I'm only asking for tweaking numbers.
What do you think?
Comments
Blandersnatching
Finder
'Auriga theme playing softly in the distant background'
Blandersnatching
Finder
24 000g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report Blandersnatching?
Are you sure you want to block Blandersnatching ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock Blandersnatching ?
UnblockCancelHBumblebee
Wannabe Scout
Stay curious!
HBumblebee
Wannabe Scout
42 100g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report HBumblebee?
Are you sure you want to block HBumblebee ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock HBumblebee ?
UnblockCancelVIPlo_fabre
Cosmonaut
This: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGLYu94U3IU remembers us that "impossible" is only a word.
VIPlo_fabre
Cosmonaut
54 100g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report lo_fabre?
Are you sure you want to block lo_fabre ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock lo_fabre ?
UnblockCancelHBumblebee
Wannabe Scout
Stay curious!
HBumblebee
Wannabe Scout
42 100g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report HBumblebee?
Are you sure you want to block HBumblebee ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock HBumblebee ?
UnblockCancelVIPlo_fabre
Cosmonaut
This: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGLYu94U3IU remembers us that "impossible" is only a word.
VIPlo_fabre
Cosmonaut
54 100g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report lo_fabre?
Are you sure you want to block lo_fabre ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock lo_fabre ?
UnblockCancelgardg10
Newcomer
gardg10
Newcomer
13 600g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report gardg10?
Are you sure you want to block gardg10 ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock gardg10 ?
UnblockCancelOut of Vision
The OUT OF VISION status is given by the dev team to ideas that are not compatible with their vision of the game or technically not feasible.
Anonymous
status updated 8 years ago
Report comment
Why do you report Anonymous?
Are you sure you want to block Anonymous ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock Anonymous ?
UnblockCancelVIPlo_fabre
Cosmonaut
This: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGLYu94U3IU remembers us that "impossible" is only a word.
VIPlo_fabre
Cosmonaut
54 100g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report lo_fabre?
Are you sure you want to block lo_fabre ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock lo_fabre ?
UnblockCancelModerate comment
Annotate comment