Video going over the map editor: Map Maker Tutorial w/ William Dyce | HUMANKIND - Twitch At 26:53 a viewer asks a question "Will premade maps ship with the game" This is the LEAD DESIGNER and another guy with him who made the game - and they both answer "I don't know" I was shocked when I saw this..... anyone working on the game should be able to answer this question. Now I have my question answered how the game went live with oil not spawning answered.
You are the lead designer... how the hell do you not know the answer to a basic question like this? I can assure you of one thing.... if I was lead designer of a game (or anything) you couldn't ask a single question about what is in the product I couldn't answer. I mean you MADE the game, how do you not know? That is like.... I can't even think up a comparison.... Keep in mind this video was made like 3 days before the game released... not when it was months out. How do you MAKE the game and not know? Can anyone explain this to me?
If I was making the game, right off the top of my head, I would be able to tell you the following: What map sizes were, how many units were in the game, and what there combat and moves were, (plus or minus 5) How many techs (plus or minus 5) What the different difficulty settings did, how many cultures were in the game and what their bonuses were, what resources were in the game (might miss a few at most) and any and all basic workings of the game.
I have not made a game, but I have 100s and 100s of hours modding games, from Civ - Stellaris - Fallout - Skyrim. I can tell you right now, when I was working on those mods I could tell you anything you wanted to know about those games. I can tell you right now I'd constantly be over the shoulder of everyone working on my game. I don't know, I had to share this and ask how this is possible. Am I ignorant? Am I crazy? What does a lead game developer do then? This blew my mind.
Lead Designer != Lead Producer. The Lead Designer can not tell you what is currently in the game most of the time, he can tell you how the game should work or what is being prepared in the future.
Also keep in mind that everything has to pass through QA as well, including maps and scenarios (for those coming from Civ 5 and 6). So "I do not know" is a pretty valid answer as there are at least two other people who need to approve that content before it makes it in game.
It is one thing being a sole modder but a completely different thing working as part of a larger team.
I fully understand it is a team job, anyone on the project should be able to answer simple questions about their game. "Will maps ship with the game" is about as softball a question as you can get, if you can't answer that it is clear you are not very involved in the project, at least not in the right areas. What exactly does he do then? I imagine the scene from the Simpsons where (back when it good, 20+ years ago) where Homer became team leader at a new nuclear power plant (we all know he knows nothing about it) and was like "um... are you guys working?" "Yes" "Well.... can you work any harder?" "sure thing boss"
So if he doesn't know what is in his own game (nor does the guy with him) What exactly DO they do? Again, that is a pretty basic question anyone working on the game should know.
Cruor34
Newcomer
Cruor34
Newcomer
2 500g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report Cruor34?
Are you sure you want to block Cruor34 ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock Cruor34 ?
UnblockCancelMelliores
Musician
Melliores
Musician
25 300g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report Melliores?
Are you sure you want to block Melliores ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock Melliores ?
UnblockCancelKyneSilverhide
Guardian Maker
KyneSilverhide
Guardian Maker
38 800g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report KyneSilverhide?
Are you sure you want to block KyneSilverhide ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock KyneSilverhide ?
UnblockCancelCruor34
Newcomer
Cruor34
Newcomer
2 500g2g ptsReport comment
Why do you report Cruor34?
Are you sure you want to block Cruor34 ?
BlockCancelAre you sure you want to unblock Cruor34 ?
UnblockCancel