Logo Platform
logo amplifiers simplified

[ KI ? (Was solved but appeared again)] Demilitarisation zone doesn’t give “trespassing ” status

Reply
Copied to clipboard!
2 years ago
Jan 5, 2023, 5:17:51 PM

Demilitarisation affinity gives only leverage from enemy units, but don’t applies “trespassing” status.

(I was at war with AI and dmz didn’t take hp from his unit, also there wasn’t trespassing icon, not sure if have saved that moment, just recently remembered that I surprised when I kept enemy unit in dmz for several turns to gain leverage, and he didn’t lose hp). 
Is it a bug or it was changed? And if it was changed then for what reason, it seems it is much weaker now

Updated a year ago.
0Send private message
2 years ago
Jan 10, 2023, 10:19:54 AM
EsoulBoy wrote:

Demilitarisation affinity gives only leverage from enemy units, but don’t applies “trespassing” status.

(I was at war with AI and dmz didn’t take hp from his unit, also there wasn’t trespassing icon, not sure if have saved that moment, just recently remembered that I surprised when I kept enemy unit in dmz for several turns to gain leverage, and he didn’t lose hp).
Is it a bug or it was changed? And if it was changed then for what reason, it seems it is much weaker now

Thats strange, I am going to move the thread to bug report, so we can take a look at it. But for that we will need from your side if you can share sae + diagnostic files (feel free to include screenshots as well).



0Send private message
2 years ago
Jan 11, 2023, 7:41:45 PM

Here the save file, it is from the same game session I have faced that bug.

Unfortunatly, I have apllied it on claimed by pink(germans) territory, but I faced it in classical era when i applied it at my claimed territory ( I was at war but I dont remember if I have attached it)

demilitarization bug.ctr

0Send private message
2 years ago
Jan 11, 2023, 7:47:02 PM

Actually, it is the buggiest session in humankind I have ever played))))

Have created around 3 threads here from this game session (mostly bugs are unmentioned before):

1) https://www.games2gether.com/amplitude-studios/humankind/forums/215-bug-reports/threads/51268-pc-steam-globalism-civic-does-not-open-trade-lines-disappear-and-stability-window?page=1#post-366053

2) https://www.games2gether.com/amplitude-studios/humankind/forums/215-bug-reports/threads/51320-air-bombing-doesn%E2%80%99t-show-damage-correctly?page=1#post-366240

Updated 2 years ago.
0Send private message
2 years ago
Jan 11, 2023, 8:05:15 PM
EsoulBoy wrote:
Actually, it is the buggiest session in humankind I have ever played))))

Agree. I hope devs will do a massive update aimed to fix most bugs than to introduce an ambitious culture pack/something similar. The majority of them (altough some became less frequent) have been known since the launch or almost.

0Send private message
2 years ago
Jan 14, 2023, 10:33:42 AM

Seems like not only me don’t have trespassing status, as the OP didn’t mentioned health damage: https://www.games2gether.com/amplitude-studios/humankind/forums/168-general/threads/51401-demilitarized-zone#post-366539

0Send private message
2 years ago
Feb 28, 2023, 2:07:03 PM

So, seems unit still don’t lose their health in dmz. Any news is it a bug or was it removed from the game  recently? 

0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 1, 2023, 4:28:10 PM
EsoulBoy wrote:

Unfortunatly, I have apllied it on claimed by pink(germans) territory, but I faced it in classical era when i applied it at my claimed territory ( I was at war but I dont remember if I have attached it)


Are you sure it's a bug? It sounds like it *might* be working as intended, if not well described.

I don't have my game open at the moment, so here's the DMZ description I am using: Fandom.com Humankind wiki - Diplomatic affinity page

If you played a DMZ on the pink player's territory, their units would not be affected. (The DMZ description is ambiguous enough that I wouldn't have thought it would generate leverage either, but from experience and as you pointed out in your OP... it does.)

From my own experiences, if you play a DMZ on your own territory, units from a player you are at war with will not be affected with trespassing but would still generate leverage. The war status seems to trump trespassing in general (whether through DMZ or not). On a related note, I don't think you are even allowed to place a DMZ on a territory owned by a player you are at war with.


Hopefully someone will investigate your save file and help clear up the confusion.

edit: I've noticed devs have been fairly quick to respond in the Bug Report thread. Perhaps you might post there as well.

Updated 2 years ago.
0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 1, 2023, 4:56:43 PM

Yeah, that why  I was asking: as TWR came out I used DMZ during a war with AI and I  remember that it put trespassing status on enemy units, so I had advantage in that region and that was amazing for tactics. But during last game I couldn’t trigger trespassing status at all: not during war, nor at peaceful times. So now I don’t understand when it is applied (

Updated 2 years ago.
0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 2, 2023, 8:44:43 AM
EsoulBoy wrote:

Yeah, that why  I was asking: as TWR came out I used DMZ during a war with AI and I  remember that it put trespassing status on enemy units, so I had advantage in that region and that was amazing for tactics. But during last game I couldn’t trigger trespassing status at all: not during war, nor at peaceful times. So now I don’t understand when it is applied (

Would you mind to share with us save + diagnostic files?

0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 2, 2023, 9:41:23 AM
EsoulBoy wrote:

Here the save file, it is from the same game session I have faced that bug.

Unfortunatly, I have apllied it on claimed by pink(germans) territory, but I faced it in classical era when i applied it at my claimed territory ( I was at war but I dont remember if I have attached it)

demilitarization bug.ctr

As for game when dmz dealt damage during the war, unfortunately, that game was on TWR release, so I don’t have that safe file. But here the safe file for the game when trespassing status is not applied. But maybe there are really some rules when it shouldn’t be applied, and all works properly, I don’t know((

0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 3, 2023, 6:48:55 PM

Here is an example of what I think EsoulBoy was talking about, with save game files & diagnostics attached.

Was playing my latest game [PC/Steam V1.0.21.3740-510 (64-bit Standalone, build:284208)]

and started as Sumeria. Not currently at war with anyone. Green player (Phonecians, no treaties) sent an army of 4 into my outpost'd territory of Nenque 

I applied DMZ to the territory. This seemed to trigger the leverage drop (possibly coincidence?) seen in pic and applied the DMZ flag to Green's army. There was no trespass grievance on the diplomacy screen - which I was expecting because of the leverage drop, but on the other hand I had read that the trespass wasn't actually applied until the next turn. Saved game as [trespass1]. Advanced turn.

Green moved their army further into my territory. This is when pic below was taken. Still no trespass flag applied to Green's units. Saved game as [trespass2]. Advanced turn.

Still no trespass flag, no unit health damage to Green's army. Pink player (Harappans, no open border treaty) actually entered with an army of 4. No leverage drop, no grievance trigger. DMZ flag applied to Pink's army.

I think the natural inclination is to assume that these armies *should* be marked as trespassing. The in-game tooltip (see pic) certainly makes it sound like they should.


TRESPASS2.ctr

Trespass1.ctr  

auto-save 20093.ctr

auto-save 20094.ctr

TrespassDiagnostics.zip

Updated 2 years ago.
0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 3, 2023, 7:16:16 PM
glenjen75 wrote:

Here is an example of what I think EsoulBoy was talking about, with save game files & diagnostics attached.

Was playing my latest game [PC/Steam V1.0.21.3740-510 (64-bit Standalone, build:284208)]

and started as Sumeria. Not currently at war with anyone. Green player (Phonecians, no treaties) sent an army of 4 into my outpost'd territory of Nenque 

I applied DMZ to the territory. This seemed to trigger the leverage drop (possibly coincidence?) seen in pic and applied the DMZ flag to Green's army. There was no trespass grievance on the diplomacy screen - which I was expecting because of the leverage drop, but on the other hand I had read that the trespass wasn't actually applied until the next turn. Saved game as [trespass1]. Advanced turn.

Green moved their army further into my territory. This is when pic below was taken. Still no trespass flag applied to Green's units. Saved game as [trespass2]. Advanced turn.

Still no trespass flag, no unit health damage to Green's army. Pink player (Harappans, no open border treaty) actually entered with an army of 4. No leverage drop, no grievance trigger. DMZ flag applied to Pink's army.

I think the natural inclination is to assume that these armies *should* be marked as trespassing. The in-game tooltip (see pic) certainly makes it sound like they should.


TRESPASS2.ctr

Trespass1.ctr  

auto-save 20093.ctr

auto-save 20094.ctr

TrespassDiagnostics.zip

Thank you, glenjen, it is truly what I was speaking about: the trespassing status is not applied, while it looks like it should be applied, as those units are seem to be not “authorised”. The same thing during the war. Btw on TWR beta or release it was applied even during the war, and there were always two icons of leverage drop and tresspassing.

0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 8, 2023, 10:12:43 AM

Soooooo, any news is this truly a bug or huge misunderstanding? *emoji of  pointing each other fingers*

Updated 2 years ago.
0Send private message
2 years ago
Mar 9, 2023, 1:45:59 PM

Hello!


Sorry for the late answer but the issue you've spotted is indeed a bug, the units present in a territory that has an outpost and a Demilitarized Zone should have the trespassing status. An issue has been added on our side and has been brought up to the attention of the team!


Sorry for the inconvenience and thank you very much for taking the time to send us this bug report!

0Send private message
0Send private message0Send private message0Send private message
a year ago
Jun 24, 2023, 1:24:51 PM

Yes, this bug definetly appeared again, here the save file (dmz at my south territory, just send there nearest unit   dmz bug new.ctr). Shall i create a new bug report? 


I also didnt see tresspassing status for foreign territories at streams, so believe this bug truly appeared again

Updated a year ago.
0Send private message
?

Click here to login

Reply
Comment