Logo Platform
logo amplifiers simplified

Amplitude, you need to respond to these concerns

Copied to clipboard!
3 years ago
Jul 9, 2021, 12:17:50 AM

Around a month and a half ago, the community learned about denuvo being in the game, and since then its become the largest trending topic on this site, with 1 post about it having just gained over 1000 views in under a month, and another has passed 900, both posts do not speak positively about denuvo in humankind, one of which is a almost pure negative response. This is not good for humankind, denuvo is one of the most hated anti-cheat devices on the internet and it will make people very reluctant to buy games with denuvo, ive already heard people are refunding their pre orders. The community wants answers, how long will denuvo be on humankind, will it have any restrictions, what caused you to place it in the game? 

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 9, 2021, 12:27:02 AM
DragonGaming wrote:
denuvo is one of the most hated anti-cheat device

Wasn't it just an anti-tamper aka DRM assistant? Denuvo anti-temper & Denuvo anti-cheat are two different things.

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 9, 2021, 7:21:59 PM
PARAdoxiBLE wrote:
DragonGaming wrote:
denuvo is one of the most hated anti-cheat device

Wasn't it just an anti-tamper aka DRM assistant? Denuvo anti-temper & Denuvo anti-cheat are two different things.

even if it is anti-tamper, denuvo as a whole is hated, and any game that even mentions denuvo will not be seen as positively as it would without denuvo.

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 9, 2021, 7:35:48 PM

Steam says that the game includes Denuvo Anti-Tamper. But the EULA also says that they can basically do whatever they want with no limitations and no responsibility for any damage done by Denuvo, so who really knows? That's the problem. No communication.

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 9, 2021, 8:26:36 PM

At the start of every Opendev intro the very first thing mentioned is the 10 year journey of codeveloping along with the community; if there was ever a time to prove it is now.


The community is speaking, let's hope they're listening as they have in the past. 

0Send private message
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 10, 2021, 4:01:43 PM

now theres another anti-denuvo post that is gaining traction with over 400 views, this is spiraling out of control, that makes it 3 anti-denuvo and if stretched, anti-amplitude posts that are trending now, and i expect it to get only worse.

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 10, 2021, 4:34:39 PM
DragonGaming wrote:
PARAdoxiBLE wrote:
DragonGaming wrote:
denuvo is one of the most hated anti-cheat device

Wasn't it just an anti-tamper aka DRM assistant? Denuvo anti-temper & Denuvo anti-cheat are two different things.

even if it is anti-tamper, denuvo as a whole is hated, and any game that even mentions denuvo will not be seen as positively as it would without denuvo.

Reactions are actually different. The cases of Denuvo anti-cheat of DOOM Eternal or Vanguard anti-cheat of Valorant were highly controversial to the extent of id deciding to scrap it from DOOM while Denuvo antI-tamper is used quite frequently.

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 10, 2021, 9:26:08 PM

i can safely say that my post can be considered the 4th trending posts in regards about denuvo with now over 300 views, and worse a 5th post about denuvo has arisen a hour ago as of this comment, and already has over 200 views. yes, 200 views in less than an hour, in less than 60 minutes after being posted. Its official, this is now out of control.

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 2:12:40 AM

Why can't these anti-Denuvo threads be merged? One sticky at the top of the board will fix this issue. It seems it's the same folks who are posting in them or reading them so of course it's just going to amplify the noise created by a small number of posters.

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 6:50:28 AM

I'm all for tidy forums, but belittling problems isn't a solution. Topic obviously have traction among many players, not only here, but also on Steam, Reddit and wherever else you go.

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 7:10:52 AM
Kutuzov wrote:

Why can't these anti-Denuvo threads be merged? One sticky at the top of the board will fix this issue. It seems it's the same folks who are posting in them or reading them so of course it's just going to amplify the noise created by a small number of posters.

That's a good point. If there are are other threads still active I'll merge them. 

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 9:37:53 AM
Sublustris wrote:

I'm all for tidy forums, but belittling problems isn't a solution. Topic obviously have traction among many players, not only here, but also on Steam, Reddit and wherever else you go.

How is asking for these threads to be merged and stickied belittling their issues or problems? While I'm not particularly concerned about this issue myself (i.e, I am going to keep my pre-order and play the game Denuvo or not), I certainly respect people's viewpoint and am not going to object to their concerns at all. Stickying it keeps the topic on the front page for as long as it is stickied which means it is easy for anyone who wishes to read about the issue to find it. It's the opposite of belittling unless you wish to demonstrate to us how it is not? 

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 12:43:05 PM

I will. This is belittling:


Kutuzov wrote:
same folks who are posting in them or reading them
Kutuzov wrote:
noise created by a small number of posters

What you are saying here is that Denuvo is not an issue (because it isn't for you, duh), so you conclude that only vocal minority will grumble about it or be interested in the topic. Well you are wrong. Have a pleasant day.

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 3:32:10 PM
Kutuzov wrote:
Sublustris wrote:

I'm all for tidy forums, but belittling problems isn't a solution. Topic obviously have traction among many players, not only here, but also on Steam, Reddit and wherever else you go.

How is asking for these threads to be merged and stickied belittling their issues or problems? While I'm not particularly concerned about this issue myself (i.e, I am going to keep my pre-order and play the game Denuvo or not), I certainly respect people's viewpoint and am not going to object to their concerns at all. Stickying it keeps the topic on the front page for as long as it is stickied which means it is easy for anyone who wishes to read about the issue to find it. It's the opposite of belittling unless you wish to demonstrate to us how it is not? 

It looks like a mod agreed to merge topics, but not to sticky the merged topic. That's reducing overall visibility by quite a lot.

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 11, 2021, 6:15:55 PM
Sublustris wrote:

I will. This is belittling:


Kutuzov wrote:
same folks who are posting in them or reading them
Kutuzov wrote:
noise created by a small number of posters

What you are saying here is that Denuvo is not an issue (because it isn't for you, duh), so you conclude that only vocal minority will grumble about it or be interested in the topic. Well you are wrong. Have a pleasant day.

Very well said Sublustris, i agree 100% with what you said and thanks for the post

Updated 2 years ago.
0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 12, 2021, 2:59:10 AM
Sublustris wrote:

I will. This is belittling:


Kutuzov wrote:
same folks who are posting in them or reading them
Kutuzov wrote:
noise created by a small number of posters

What you are saying here is that Denuvo is not an issue (because it isn't for you, duh), so you conclude that only vocal minority will grumble about it or be interested in the topic. Well you are wrong. Have a pleasant day.

But you are the same group of posters.


And the tactic of creating as much noise as possible to fool the opposition into thinking your numbers are greater than they actually are is as old as the hills. That is what Dragongaming was alluding to in his post above which attracted my attention. More on that later.


No, Denuvo is not the issue for me that it is for you. I don't much like that it's there and if they remove it, I will be happy that they have done so. But if they decide to keep it, it's just not going to make that much difference to me because I don't share your passion for this issue and I will play the game regardless. How representative that makes my stance, I have no idea. Well, actually I do but I'm not opening that can of worms here ;)


One final point before I scurry off with my tail between my legs after a well-deserved beating. This discussion is a matter of public record and it should be clear to anyone who is reading with a clear head what is being said and what is being manufactured for reasons. My intervention starts with Dragongaming's post above which elicited a response from a moderator. I have not been belittling the issue at all. I understand that this disproportionate overreaction because someone had the temerity to suggest merging Denuvo threads here and stickying it at the top of the page has caused some offence to you.

  1. Offending people was not my intention.
  2. Neither you not your cause is being attacked.

There should have been no need for either of those statements to be made either but I understand the passion I'm confronting and feel it is necessary to do so.


Now, if you wish to keep taking my posts out of context and manufacturing offence from them, I could be encouraged to stay in the ring but otherwise, I'm content to let this matter rest.

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 12, 2021, 6:40:31 AM

You keep repeating that they are minority, but they aren't - steam forums were flooded with denuvo threads for almost a month, reddit had large threads until they got deleted.

The hate for denuvo is pretty universal among gamers wherever you go. You must understand, that it's purpose is purely to satisfy publisher/developer and nothing more. It's inferior in every way to legit players. Not every tech-savy aware of its presence, even less how it works, but those that know see they have zero gains and myriad of actual and potential issues with it.

0Send private message
3 years ago
Jul 12, 2021, 7:22:38 AM
Sublustris wrote:

You keep repeating that they are minority, but they aren't - steam forums were flooded with denuvo threads for almost a month, reddit had large threads until they got deleted.

The hate for denuvo is pretty universal among gamers wherever you go. You must understand, that it's purpose is purely to satisfy publisher/developer and nothing more. It's inferior in every way to legit players. Not every tech-savy aware of its presence, even less how it works, but those that know see they have zero gains and myriad of actual and potential issues with it.

Gamers who post on discussion boards, these boards, Steam, Reddit, wherever are already a very tiny fraction of gamers as a whole. This game will sell hundreds of thousands of copies but you will never see more than 1 or 2% of these folks posting online or even participating passively here by viewing threads. I'd say overall that only a fraction of a percentage point of actual gamers bother with discussion boards except for multiplayer games.


You will find several of these same posters making the same posts on each of these boards as well amplifying their presence. I'm not saying that there's anything 'wrong' with that either but neither is there anything wrong with pointing this out. Doing so seems to have offended some of you in this discussion for some reason. I recognise a few of the names of posters here from elsewhere and you won't find me active in any other discussion board about Denuvo than here because I'm not particularly concerned about it and am happy to let the decision lie with the developers and I'm not going to bully them into it. I've read about Denuvo and I recognise some of the points of concern that are repeated here*, maybe even exaggerated a little from time to time to make it sound like one report is 'many reports' to make others who are not so inclined to do the reading for themselves more frightened than they need to be. I will also determine for myself what its purpose is, thank you. I hope you can respect that people do not like being told what to think. ;)


People who post on these boards often have concerns which they often can't all agree upon further making any claim to be a 'majority' even more ridiculous. So, yes, some gamers do hate Denuvo. Nobody disputes that but while those that do are noisy and have a substantial online presence compared to the likes of me, you're still far from a majority.


* edit to add a link to a post on Humankind's Steam discussion boards regarding this controversy ...


https://steamcommunity.com/app/1124300/discussions/0/3057363335742801947/?ctp=3#c3057364366988386790

Updated 3 years ago.
0Send private message
Comment