Happened again. Played another game focused solely on this achievement. I managed to get to 13 stars before the game stopped tracking them. I earned Nikolia, but again finished the game with 18 and should have had Ada.

Is it only me? Has anyone had any trouble with any of these earn X amount of stars achievements?

(Can't seem to attach a save in a post's edit so, making this post)

Second save file were Ada achievement should have been given:

Game 3.ctr

Just finished a game with 18 builder stars (had the stars finished on turn 260), Progress showed 10 (which was the same I had after my last game) so it must have stopped after 3 eras already or just didnt register anything for this round.

Thanks, glad to know its not just me. I just made one last attempt at this achievement for a while I think. I hit 18 again, but was given 14 in the achievement.

I suspect it may be only counting the first game ever completed. My tallies haven't updated since then.

Same issue here. And not only those 18 of type achievements (or 12). 

"Millionaires Club", "I'm a Lumberjack..." , "Wonder-Full" also don't track correctly. Probably some others like "The Stars My Destination", "Material World". 

The "Millionaires Club" and "Wonder-Full" dropped it's track to 0 for me after I started second game and never went an inch up since.

It looks like tracking stops when u load a game, no matter if it's the same one, or a new one.

Also I can't seem to get "Falling Out". It says "Nuke the capital of an Empire that was an ally at the turn beginning." And I specifically tried to do this in 3 different games to no avail. I don't know what am I doing wrong. (had and ally - broke an alliance - declared surprise war - did send a nuke to the capital - all in same turn)

Yeah, same issue here.  Just did an achievement playthrough where I got every era star in 1 run... I expected to get a bunch of popups after finishing.  I didn't get any achievements at all for the game xD.

The "get them in all sitting rumor" is true, I can confirm as I have all of the 18 star achivements. You cannot make a single load, EVER to get them. I did the last few in the beta branch, so that may be what fixed them, but I also got a few before that. Trigger seems to be the narrator commenting on "wow, X stars of Y types, impressive!"

As for some of the more "do this specific thing" achivements, yhea they still seem quite bugged.

Did some testing on that one:

- Tried to take every star [

> Failed within to 300 turns limit.

> Made it after some more rounds.

- Tried to take every star in one category by not going into next era until I do have 3 stars in that category.

> That was no problem.

- Tried to take every star in one category by getting 3 stars before completing the 7 stars necessary to progress into next era. [

> This was harder. My best score was  17 stars before entering last era.

Nothing worked. Progress still at 9/12 and 9/18.

Was not given the achievement for playing in a multiplayer game just now.

Hello all,

Good thread here ! Exactly what I was looking for :D

For the 18 stars, you can unlock it even after the end of the game. As mentioned, no loading permitted but after the 75 turns (yes, if you can't load it would be a nightmare to go with 600 turns !) you still get the achievements if you continue the game. Just got some of them at the 83 turn. You can basically get all of them in one game if you wait for having all the stars before switching era.

Unbend the Knee: I have never been a vassal but I got this one still ... by launching a surprise war at my own vassal !
However, I didn't get the "How the mighty has fallen" when I made an alliance with him afterwards. From Kuwaken post I understand this is bugged even if you do it properly.

Landstalker: like Kuwaken said, it is not possible to perform at least on a normal map. I'll try next on a "Huge map" and see if we can.

So i've done almost all the achievements;

Wonder-Full is definitely bugged;

I've tried Landstalker on a huge map and not triggered it, I'm not sure if it may be a difficulty thing maybe.

Falling Out was done via some outpost shenanigans, where I "traded" some territories with an enemy so they had an outpost next to my ally's capital (started several wars and instantly surrendered giving territory) and then nuked that outpost with a maxed out thermo nuke which also hit my ally's capital

How the Mighty has fallen does indeed trigger correctly (you need to have been a vassal and then make an alliance with your liege)